The single family home was an artifact of the blue model world. Before World War II, it was common for many generations of a family to live together. Before social security, grandparents didn’t have the money for independent living; children and grandchildren were a safety net. Often, extended families would live together, sharing chores, cooperating with child care and other activities.
But postwar suburbia changed all that: each nuclear family was supposed to be an island unto itself, and zoning laws in many American cities and towns changed to make illegal the kind of multi-family living that had once been the norm.Monday, April 11, 2016
by Bill McBride on 4/11/2016 11:28:00 AM
With the ten year yield falling to 1.73%, there has been
some discussion about whether mortgage rates will fall to new lows. Based on an
historical relationship, 30-year rates should currently be around 3.7%.
As of Friday, Mortgage News Daily reported:
"the average lender continuing to quote conventional 30yr fixed rates of
3.625% on top tier scenarios." Pretty close to expected.
The graph shows the relationship between the monthly 10 year Treasury Yield and 30 year mortgage rates from the Freddie Mac survey.
The graph shows the relationship between the monthly 10 year Treasury Yield and 30 year mortgage rates from the Freddie Mac survey.
Currently
the 10 year Treasury yield is at 1.73% and 30 year mortgage rates were at 3.59%
according to the Freddie Mac survey
last week.
To reach new lows (on the Freddie Mac survey), mortgage rates would have to fall below the 3.35% lows in 2012.For that to happen, based on the historical relationship, the Ten Year yield would have fall to under 1.5%.
So I don't expect new lows on mortgage rates unless the Ten Year yield falls further.
To reach new lows (on the Freddie Mac survey), mortgage rates would have to fall below the 3.35% lows in 2012.For that to happen, based on the historical relationship, the Ten Year yield would have fall to under 1.5%.
So I don't expect new lows on mortgage rates unless the Ten Year yield falls further.
Monday, April 4, 2016
Was El Nino A Hype?
Posted by Bill McBride on 4/03/2016 08:22:00 PM 149 Comments
The El Niño
Bust in California
by Bill McBride on 4/03/2016 11:10:00 AM
From Accuweather: El Nino-induced snow proves to be
'disappointing' for drought-stricken California
Much-needed mountain snow and rain returned to California
this winter, but fell short of expectations amid a super El Niño.
The official snow season for California's Sierra Nevada came
to an end at the start of April on a below-normal note and one that AccuWeather
Senior Meteorologist Ken Clark called "disappointing."
The amount of water stored in the snow for the entire
mountain chain averaged 14 percent below normal on April 1, according to the
California Cooperative Snow Surveys.
The northern Sierra fared better than the southern Sierra
with the amount of water in the snow averaging only 5 percent below normal,
compared to the 27 percent below normal in the south.
"The numbers are not anywhere near what many had wanted
going into the winter," Clark said. "The much-heralded El Niño
brought more snow than the previous four years, but that was not hard to
accomplish."
Here are some excellent graphs showing snow water content in
the Sierra. This was close to an average year in the Northern Sierra, but below
average in Central and South. There was more rain and snow than the previous
four years, but this will still be considered year 5 of the drought.
Tyndall CreekNote: For Pacific Crest Trail and John Muir
Trail hikers, I recommend using the Upper Tyndall Creek sensor to track the
snow conditions. This is the fifth dry year in a row along the JMT, but there
should be more water along the trail this summer than the previous four years,
and still not too much snow on the passes.
This graph shows the snow water content for Upper Tyndall
Creek for the last 9 years. There is more snow than the previous four years,
but that isn't saying much.
ARCADIA MANSIONIZATION BALLOT MEASURE INITIATIVE
In November 2015 I was interviewed by Arcadia Weekly regarding the Arcadia Ballot Measure Initiative which recently cleared signature verification with the County. My conclusion: passsage of the initiative would be catastrophic to Arcadia residential property values. Please read the Arcadia Weekly article and the following blog post article about the initiative. Eric Rosa
Eric Rosa, Realtor Explains Arcadia Residential Land Investment
By Joe Taglieri
As the war of words over residential development in Arcadia steadily intensifies, members of the local real estate community have recently begun publicly speaking out about efforts to limit home size.
Throughout the last couple of months Joe Sira of Dilbeck Real Estate and a member of the Arcadia Association of Realtors have consistently attended City Council meetings to denounce a proposed voter initiative that seeks to revise design guidelines for single-family residences.
Last week another Arcadia-based real estate professional added his perspective to the debate. Like Sira, Eric Rosa foresees potentially dire consequences for stakeholders’ property values and real estate developers’ profit margins if the measure, which is still in the petition-gathering phase and not yet on the upcoming election’s ballot, becomes law.
“When you hear that big homes are hurting real estate values, and particularly in southwest Arcadia, it’s not true,” Rosa told the council at its Nov. 3 study session.
Referring to ballot measure supporters’ petition drive, Rosa added, “When we see people standing in front of the post office … you will never hear real economics, all it is ‘mansionization, mansionization.'”
In an interview Rosa presented a detailed set of economic data to augment his thoughts on the voter initiative and the city’s ongoing zoning code update process.
Rosa believes the measure’s petition effort will be successful in gathering the more than 3,000 signatures needed to qualify for the April 12 ballot.
He cautioned that if voters enact the proposed tougher limits on square footage, the policy revamp “can’t be overturned by elected officials” and would require a ballot initiative in 2018 to rescind voter-approved code amendments.
“The thing that concerns me about the referendum is how drastic and significant the proposed zoning ordinances are relative to what we have now,” Rosa said. “They could have anywhere near to a 35 to 50 percent decrease in teardown property values, and I think there will be ancillary reductions in other property values.”
To illustrate his point, Rosa – a 31-year Arcadia resident with a background in real estate finance who currently is a realtor at the local Coldwell Banker office – offered what he called a hypothetical “case study” examining the initiative’s potential impact on the realty market. Rosa’s bottom line: a nearly 50 percent decline in lot value if voters enact the proposed design guidelines for new homes.
Rosa used current building regulations to reflect the following scenario, which would result in a developer erecting an 8,200-square-foot, two-story home with a four-car garage, high-ceiling foyer and covered patios and porches on a 20,000-square-foot lot:
Land (20,000 square feet x $95) $1.9 million; construction costs (8,200 square feet x $200) $1.64 million; costs related to architecture and engineering (8,200 square feet x $20) $164,000; city and school fees (8,200 square feet x $8.25 + $1,000) $68,650; building contingency, legal and miscellaneous costs (8,200 square feet x $7.50) $61,500; bank financing interest $90,000; total cost about $3.9 million.
Rosa then estimated the following for the newly built home’s sale proceeds and return on investment for the property owner:
Sale price (8,200 square feet x $625) approximately $5.1 million; sale expenses (6 percent for marketing, realtor commission, title transfer, miscellaneous) $307,500; net sale price about $4.8 million; construction project total cost about $3.9 million; Net profit $892,500 or 23 percent of project cost.
Rosa also created another scenario based on the voter initiative’s proposed building rules – 35 percent of lot coverage for the first 10,000 square feet of a lot and 15 percent for remaining square footage over the first 10,000, as well as total square footage reflecting space consumed by the garage, porches, patios and the hypothetical residence’s high-ceiling foyer, which counts for double the floor area’s square footage:
Land (20,000 square feet x $50) $1 million; construction costs (4,300 square feet x $200) $860,000; costs related to architecture and engineering (4,300 square feet x $20) $86,000; city and school fees (4,300 square feet x $8.25 + $1,000) $36,475; building contingency, legal and miscellaneous costs (4,300 square feet x $7.50) $32,250; bank financing interest $40,000; total cost about $2.1 million.
According to Rosa profit shrinks considerably as a result of the proposed code revision:
Sale price (4,300 square feet x $625) approximately $2.7 million; sale expenses (6 percent for marketing, realtor commission, title transfer, miscellaneous) $161,250; net sale price about $2.5 million; construction project total cost about $2.1 million; Net profit $471,250 or 23 percent of project cost.
Rosa acknowledged that his conservative hypothetical focuses on the most consistent elements of a real estate investment. Additional factors such as the amount of time it takes to complete a construction project then sell a new home affects the overall return on investment as does the proportion of an investor’s actual cash stake in a property versus the amount of financing provided by a bank.
Rosa’s model concludes that for both sets of development guidelines an investor’s “annual equity return” amounts to 36 percent based on a 15-month time frame with 50 percent leverage.
“Most developers wouldn’t use these numbers, they’d want more,” Rosa said. “The reason being is there’s so much risk involved. You put up a couple million bucks in this thing or even more and the market goes south, or you have a 9/11, or some recession goes off and the stock market blows up, or the Chinese decide not to come and buy your house and you know what? You’ve got a big liability, and that’s why everybody isn’t a developer.”
Citing data on new home sales from the industry-standard Multiple Listing Service, or MLS, Rosa reported that the average lot size in Arcadia was 17,098 feet, the average new home size was 6,628 square feet and the average new home sold for $3.9 million.
“Demand for new Arcadia homes appears strong and slightly greater than demand in 2014,” Rosa said, countering claims that “China’s recent economic malaise will result in a decreasing demand” for new homes in Arcadia.
Through Oct. 1 “MLS reported 55 new Arcadia … home sales. This sale pace/velocity is ahead of 2014’s pace,” Rosa added. “For all of 2014 MLS reported 58 new Arcadia … home sales” with a median sale price of $3.2 million and average $610 per square foot, an average size of 5,563 square feet on a 14,207-square-foot lot and lot coverage of 32 percent.
Eric Rosa, Realtor Explains Arcadia Residential Land Investment
By Joe Taglieri
As the war of words over residential development in Arcadia steadily intensifies, members of the local real estate community have recently begun publicly speaking out about efforts to limit home size.
Throughout the last couple of months Joe Sira of Dilbeck Real Estate and a member of the Arcadia Association of Realtors have consistently attended City Council meetings to denounce a proposed voter initiative that seeks to revise design guidelines for single-family residences.
Last week another Arcadia-based real estate professional added his perspective to the debate. Like Sira, Eric Rosa foresees potentially dire consequences for stakeholders’ property values and real estate developers’ profit margins if the measure, which is still in the petition-gathering phase and not yet on the upcoming election’s ballot, becomes law.
“When you hear that big homes are hurting real estate values, and particularly in southwest Arcadia, it’s not true,” Rosa told the council at its Nov. 3 study session.
Referring to ballot measure supporters’ petition drive, Rosa added, “When we see people standing in front of the post office … you will never hear real economics, all it is ‘mansionization, mansionization.'”
In an interview Rosa presented a detailed set of economic data to augment his thoughts on the voter initiative and the city’s ongoing zoning code update process.
Rosa believes the measure’s petition effort will be successful in gathering the more than 3,000 signatures needed to qualify for the April 12 ballot.
He cautioned that if voters enact the proposed tougher limits on square footage, the policy revamp “can’t be overturned by elected officials” and would require a ballot initiative in 2018 to rescind voter-approved code amendments.
“The thing that concerns me about the referendum is how drastic and significant the proposed zoning ordinances are relative to what we have now,” Rosa said. “They could have anywhere near to a 35 to 50 percent decrease in teardown property values, and I think there will be ancillary reductions in other property values.”
To illustrate his point, Rosa – a 31-year Arcadia resident with a background in real estate finance who currently is a realtor at the local Coldwell Banker office – offered what he called a hypothetical “case study” examining the initiative’s potential impact on the realty market. Rosa’s bottom line: a nearly 50 percent decline in lot value if voters enact the proposed design guidelines for new homes.
Rosa used current building regulations to reflect the following scenario, which would result in a developer erecting an 8,200-square-foot, two-story home with a four-car garage, high-ceiling foyer and covered patios and porches on a 20,000-square-foot lot:
Land (20,000 square feet x $95) $1.9 million; construction costs (8,200 square feet x $200) $1.64 million; costs related to architecture and engineering (8,200 square feet x $20) $164,000; city and school fees (8,200 square feet x $8.25 + $1,000) $68,650; building contingency, legal and miscellaneous costs (8,200 square feet x $7.50) $61,500; bank financing interest $90,000; total cost about $3.9 million.
Rosa then estimated the following for the newly built home’s sale proceeds and return on investment for the property owner:
Sale price (8,200 square feet x $625) approximately $5.1 million; sale expenses (6 percent for marketing, realtor commission, title transfer, miscellaneous) $307,500; net sale price about $4.8 million; construction project total cost about $3.9 million; Net profit $892,500 or 23 percent of project cost.
Rosa also created another scenario based on the voter initiative’s proposed building rules – 35 percent of lot coverage for the first 10,000 square feet of a lot and 15 percent for remaining square footage over the first 10,000, as well as total square footage reflecting space consumed by the garage, porches, patios and the hypothetical residence’s high-ceiling foyer, which counts for double the floor area’s square footage:
Land (20,000 square feet x $50) $1 million; construction costs (4,300 square feet x $200) $860,000; costs related to architecture and engineering (4,300 square feet x $20) $86,000; city and school fees (4,300 square feet x $8.25 + $1,000) $36,475; building contingency, legal and miscellaneous costs (4,300 square feet x $7.50) $32,250; bank financing interest $40,000; total cost about $2.1 million.
According to Rosa profit shrinks considerably as a result of the proposed code revision:
Sale price (4,300 square feet x $625) approximately $2.7 million; sale expenses (6 percent for marketing, realtor commission, title transfer, miscellaneous) $161,250; net sale price about $2.5 million; construction project total cost about $2.1 million; Net profit $471,250 or 23 percent of project cost.
Rosa acknowledged that his conservative hypothetical focuses on the most consistent elements of a real estate investment. Additional factors such as the amount of time it takes to complete a construction project then sell a new home affects the overall return on investment as does the proportion of an investor’s actual cash stake in a property versus the amount of financing provided by a bank.
Rosa’s model concludes that for both sets of development guidelines an investor’s “annual equity return” amounts to 36 percent based on a 15-month time frame with 50 percent leverage.
“Most developers wouldn’t use these numbers, they’d want more,” Rosa said. “The reason being is there’s so much risk involved. You put up a couple million bucks in this thing or even more and the market goes south, or you have a 9/11, or some recession goes off and the stock market blows up, or the Chinese decide not to come and buy your house and you know what? You’ve got a big liability, and that’s why everybody isn’t a developer.”
Citing data on new home sales from the industry-standard Multiple Listing Service, or MLS, Rosa reported that the average lot size in Arcadia was 17,098 feet, the average new home size was 6,628 square feet and the average new home sold for $3.9 million.
“Demand for new Arcadia homes appears strong and slightly greater than demand in 2014,” Rosa said, countering claims that “China’s recent economic malaise will result in a decreasing demand” for new homes in Arcadia.
Through Oct. 1 “MLS reported 55 new Arcadia … home sales. This sale pace/velocity is ahead of 2014’s pace,” Rosa added. “For all of 2014 MLS reported 58 new Arcadia … home sales” with a median sale price of $3.2 million and average $610 per square foot, an average size of 5,563 square feet on a 14,207-square-foot lot and lot coverage of 32 percent.
Friday, April 1, 2016
ARCADIA MEASURE ON MANSIONIZATION QUALIFIES FOR BALLOT
Arcadia Measure On Mansionization Qualifies
For Ballot
By Courtney Tompkins, The Pasadena
Star-News
POSTED: 03/31/16,
4:33 PM PDT | UPDATED: 2 HRS AGO
ARCADIA
>> Home size may ultimately come down to a vote of the people after a
resident-backed initiative targeting mansionization cleared signature
verification with the county this week.
The count
came down to the wire, though, as the initiative qualified with only one more
signature than the required 2,909, which represents 10 percent of the city’s
registered voters.
If adopted, the initiative would create a citywide floor area
ratio (FAR), which would set much tighter restrictions on square footage.
City Clerk
Lisa Mussenden said the measure could come before voters as soon as November,
along with state and national elections, or as far out as April 2018, with the
next municipal election.The city
could also opt to hold a special election, but that would cost taxpayers
upwards of $100,000, she said.
Saving
Arcadia, a local group behind the initiative, began drafting it in July in an
attempt to address unrest in the community over mansionization, which is commonly defined as the practice
of demolishing smaller, older houses and replacing them with new ones that
occupy the maximum amount of lot space possible.
The idea
came after a controversial City Council vote — made by Roger
Chandler, Sho Tay and John Wuo — that halted a citywide zoning code update and
historic preservation survey.The vote
prompted threats of recall against the trio as residents said they felt the
elected officials suspended the study as an act of retaliation over a pending lawsuit some residents filed against the city.The lawsuit,
which targeted the cumulative impacts of mansionization, has since been
settled.
Saving
Arcadia spokesman David Arvizu said the group is glad to be over the first big
hurdle, but he said they are concerned the city could keep the initiative from
going to the voters for two years.“I would be
very disappointed if the city tried to stall this out by making excuses and
delaying the process in which the residents of Arcadia can decide about what
they want to do about their city zoning codes,” he said.
But city officials are concerned that
a ballot initiative is not the way to address and some say it could hurt home
values.
“The initiative would have to have
some effect on property values and it has to have a substantial effect on
resale values,” Councilman Mickey Segal said.
Councilman Tom Beck echoed Segal’s
sentiments, calling it “much more restrictive” than what’s on the table for
passage on Tuesday.
The city is
days away from holding a public hearing on several recommended updates to its
residential development standards, including adopting a sliding scale FAR that
varies based on neighborhood and lot size.“What’s in
front of us now to approve is a perfect definition of a middle ground,” Segal
said.
Proponents
of the ballot initiative include representatives of three homeowners’
associations in northern Arcadia: April Verlato, Laurie Thompson and Richard Midgley.Verlato, a candidate for City Council, has withdrawn herself
from the group during the election but
said she still supports its efforts.
Beck said
there is still a chance the proponents will be content with the development
standards the council adopts and may choose to withdraw the initiative.
But Verlato
said it’s still too early to make that determination.
“We will
need to see what happens with the zoning code recommendations and this
election,” she said. Mussenden
said the initiative will likely go before the City Council at one of the next
two meetings, on Tuesday or April 19.
The council
still needs to accept the signature certification from the Los Angeles County
Registrar-Recorder and then make some decisions regarding it, including whether
they want to adopt the ordinance as is or conduct a study on the anticipated
impacts and place it on a future ballot.
Dan Walters:
New California Color
Is Gray,
Not Gold,
As Aging Tsunami Arrives
BY DAN
WALTERS, Sacramento Bee
dwalters@sacbee.com
From the
beach party movies of the 1960s to the hippies of the 1970s and Silicon
Valley’s baby billionaires today, California has long projected a youthful
ambiance.
That’s about
to change in a big way. The aging of California’s huge post-World War II
baby-boom generation, combined with plummeting birth and immigration rates,
means the Golden State is quickly going gray.
A huge
growth in the over-65 population, from about 4.5 million today to more than 11
million by 2050 – nearly a quarter of the state’s residents then – will disrupt
labor markets as it imposes major new costs on taxpayers for health care and
other services.
It could
also alter the state’s politics as the elderly become a decisive voting bloc,
not only because of rising numbers but because the propensity to vote increases
with age.
First, the
numbers.Roughly 11
percent of the nearly 40 million Californians today are 65-plus. The state
Department of Finance estimates that by 2020, the over-65 cohort will rise to
15 percent, then to nearly 20 percent by 2030, when the youngest of the baby
boomers will pass 65, and reach 22.3 percent by 2050, double the current
proportion.
One state
document puts it this way: “California will surpass the national average for
age by 2040 even though it is currently the sixth youngest state in the nation
with only 11 percent of its population 65 and older.
Over the
next 15 years, those passing the 65-year-old threshold will be mostly white,
but later will become a more ethnically mixed group. While the median age of
Californians as a whole is about 35 years today, the white median is 44, much
higher than that of Latinos (27), blacks (35) or Asians (38). The differentials
will narrow over the next 35 years, but even in 2050, the median age of Latinos
(38) is expected to be 11 years lower than whites (49).
The most
visible effect of these trends will be in California’s workplaces.Baby boomers
are roughly 40 percent of the 20 million Californians of working age – 25 to
64. Over the next 15 years the vast majority will leave the labor force,
claiming their pensions and Social Security payments and tapping into their
personal retirement accounts and home equity, if they have them.
Some will
continue to work part-time, but retirements will leave big holes – especially
in the ranks of workers with specialized education and skills.
The Public
Policy Institute of California has repeatedly highlighted a growing shortage of
college-educated workers due to the baby boomers’ exodus from the workforce,
the increasing proportion of jobs demanding four-year or higher degrees and
doubts about having enough Latinos to fill the jobs because “this group has
relatively low levels of educational attainment.”
“In the
coming decades,” PPIC says in one report, “slower growth in the supply of
college-educated workers
Thursday, March 31, 2016
Homeownership
Increasingly Difficult For Average Americans
by Reuters
MARCH 24, 2016, 12:54 AM EDT
E-mail Tweet
Facebook Linkedin
Share icons
Home price
growth is exceeding growth in wages.
(Reuters) –
Home prices are rising faster than wages in most of the United States, making
homeownership increasingly difficult for average Americans in some of the most
populous areas of the country, according to a report released on Thursday.
The report
found that home price growth exceeded wage growth in nearly two thirds of the
nation’s housing markets so far this year, with urban centers like San
Francisco and New York City among the least affordable.
Home prices
in 9% of the U.S. housing market are now less affordable than their historic
norms, the report by RealtyTrac found. Home buyers need to spend more of their
incomes on housing, leaving less money for other purchases.
“While the
vast majority of housing markets are still affordable by their own historic
standards, home prices are floating out of reach for average wage earners in a
growing number of U.S. housing markets,” said Daren Blomquist, senior vice
president at RealtyTrac, which monitors housing market trends.
RealtyTrac
parsed homes sales and income data in 456 U.S. counties with a combined population
of 221 million.
The report
comes after data showing house flipping, buying and selling a house to make a
quick profit in a hot housing market, had risen to record levels in some
markets, generating concerns of a price bubble.
While the
latest report could fuel those concerns, prices are still far more affordable
than during the peak of the housing bubble in 2006. In the first quarter of
this year the average wage earner needed to spend a third of their income on
monthly mortgage payments compared to more than half in 2006.
In addition,
RealtyTrac’s affordability measure, which compares house prices to wages, was
above historic norms in 99% of housing markets in 2006. After the housing
bubble burst that fell to a low of 2% in 2012 before rising to its current 9%.
Still,
prices in highly sought after housing markets leave average wage earners far
behind, RealtyTrac said.For example, to buy a median priced home in various
areas of New York City, Brooklyn and Manhattan especially, or in the San
Francisco metro area, a buyer needs to spend between 120% and 95% of the
average wage on mortgage payments.
Among
populous areas where the growth in house prices outstripped wage growth were
Los Angeles, Phoenix, and San Diego.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)